A tribute to Mariano Fortuny by Sarah Moon
Palazzo Fortuny, Venice

Peculiare di Samorì è il gesto artistico finale: “Ho sollevato col bulino un singolo filamento di colore, circuendo la testa ridipinta di nero per raggiungere la stretta di indice e pollice che in un’immagine antica reggevano un anello. Il ritratto si è fatto cerchio”. Nicola Samorì, In principio era la fine. Olio su tavola, 40x30 cm, 2016.

This omitted chapter [At Tikhon’s], is the culmination of Stavrogin’s tragedy and Dostoevsky’s loftiest artistic creation. The struggle for faith with disbelief, which grows through the duration of the whole novel, here attains its most extreme tension. The opposition of the two ideas is embodied in the encounter of two personalities — the atheist Stavrogin and the mystic Tikhon. The enigmatic hero’s secret is revealed, and the resolution, which we have so long awaited with anxiety and excitement, strikes us by its unexpectedness. Stavrogin irritably and mockingly tells Tikhon about his hallucinations: he, of course, does not believe in the apparitionst and realizes that it is a disease. Tikhon answers seriously: ‘Devils do exist beyond doubt, but the understanding of them can be greatly varied.” Then Stavrogin loses his self-possession and betrays himself. With diabolic pride he declares to Tikhon: ‘I will tell you seriously and insolently: I do believe in the devil, I do believe, canonically, in a personal one, not in an allegory, and I have no need to inquire of anyone, this is the whole thing.’
Yes, this is the whole thing: Stavrogin canonically believes in the devil, without believing in God; the proud and strong spirit, God-like in his grandeur, has renounced the Creator and closed himself off in selfness. He desired to be by himself — ‘to express his self-will.’ ‘If there is no God, I am God,’ said Kirillov. Stavrogin has realized this: he is God in his unlimited power and freedom. But in the experience of man-godhood the strong personality finds not triumph, but defeat. His power is purposeless, for there is no point of its application, his freedom is empty since it is the freedom of indifference. Stavrogin is a lie and slave to the ‘father of lies’ — the devil. The god-like personality is split into two countenances; there appears a double — ‘a nasty, little imp, one of those who have miscarried’; free God in necessarily replaced by faith in the devil. Stavrogin falls into demonic possession, practical satanism. It is his ‘credo‘: ‘I believe canonically in the devil.’ Opposed to it is Tikhon’s confession of faith. To the apostate’s question whether he believes in God: Tikhon answers, ‘I believe,… And let me not be ashamed of Your Cross, Lord…’
Two forces, the greatest in the world — faith and disbelief, God and the devil — have clashed. This instant of blinding luster has been prepared by the whole action of the novel; for this instant it was also written.
― Konstantin Mochulsky, Dostoevsky: His Life and Work